Poll: A Reviewer Calls Robert Pinkhasov's History 'Not the Last Word, but a Foundation.' Which Chapter of Bukharian Jewish History Deserves a Book of Its Own?

David Mavashev says Pinkhasov's 813-page history cannot treat every topic in depth. Readers choose which chapter, from the chala to Bukharian poets, deserves its own study.

Nov 13, 2026 - 07:19
Updated: 9 days ago
0 7
Poll: A Reviewer Calls Robert Pinkhasov's History 'Not the Last Word, but a Foundation.' Which Chapter of Bukharian Jewish History Deserves a Book of Its Own?
AI-generated editorial illustration. An open history book and archival Bukharian Jewish photographs.

This poll draws on facts reported in Bukharian Jewish Post's Nov. 12, 2026, article on David Mavashev's review of Dr. Robert Pinkhasov's book, which was published in Russian in The Bukharian Times, No. 1292 (Nov. 12–18, 2026). Quotations are our translations. The poll records reader opinion only. Results are not a scientific survey.

Dr. Robert Pinkhasov's "Bukharian Jews in the History of Centuries" is a large book: 813 pages in Russian and 783 in English, according to a review by David Mavashev, president of the Itzhak Mavashev Foundation. Mavashev called it a "fundamental work." He also wrote that a book covering several centuries, dozens of topics and the lives of more than 2,000 people cannot give every subject equally deep treatment. In his words, it is better seen "not as the last word, but as a large-scale foundation for further research."

That raises a question for readers in Queens, Israel and Florida: if the next researcher took one chapter of Bukharian Jewish history and gave it a book of its own, which chapter should it be?

What the book covers

According to the review, Pinkhasov, a Tashkent-born physician who has lived in the United States since 1992 and leads the Roshnoi public research center, worked for about a quarter-century with archives, tsarist and Soviet administrative documents, civil registration books, the pre-revolutionary press of Turkestan, memoirs and rare photographs.

The main historical section begins in the 17th century and follows the formation of Bukharian Jewish communities over the following centuries. Mavashev noted that the Jewish presence in Central Asia is much older. He drew a distinction between the ancient history of the region's Jews and the gradual formation of the people who later came to be called Bukharian Jews.

The book examines Jewish life in the Emirate of Bukhara: legal status, restrictions, relations with the Muslim population, religious life, trade, education and culture. It gives separate attention to the chala, Jews forced to convert to Islam who in many cases secretly kept their ties to Judaism. Mavashev highlighted its treatment of Rabbi Yosef Maman Maghribi, who arrived in Bukhara in the late 18th century and, the reviewer wrote, strengthened religious life and ties with other Jewish centers.

There is information on 87 of the best-known Bukharian Jewish merchants and industrialists of the 19th century, and there are sections on family life, weddings, the position of women, clothing, jewelry, cuisine, holidays and customs. Mavashev wrote that these sections matter especially now, when many elements of the old way of life have disappeared.

The reviewer said the literary history interested him most, including figures of the Judeo-Persian and Bukharian Jewish tradition such as Shohini Sherozi, Imroni, Yusuf ben Yitzhak, Khoja Hakohen, Ragib, Zabikho and Malikho. He recalled that his father, the scholar Itzhak Mavashev, wrote a dissertation on the poet Shohin but did not defend it after refusing to switch his subject to a Tajik poet.

Why the question matters

Mavashev wrote that in places the book's scale gives it an encyclopedic character, and that the analysis of broader historical processes sometimes recedes behind names and biographical details. He added that some dates, assessments and interpretations may be debated. Pinkhasov himself writes that the book does not cover every question of Bukharian Jewish history, religion, tradition and culture, according to the review.

Poll: Which chapter of Bukharian Jewish history deserves a book of its own?

  • The chala, the forced converts who kept their Judaism in secret
  • Rabbi Yosef Maman Maghribi and his work strengthening religious life in Bukhara
  • The 19th-century merchants and industrialists
  • Bukharian Jewish poets and the Judeo-Persian literary tradition, from Shohin onward
  • Daily life: weddings, the position of women, clothing, jewelry and cuisine
  • The older, ancient history of Jews in Central Asia before the 17th century
  • Something else (tell us in the comments)

Vote in the poll and share your answer. If your family has documents, letters or photographs connected to any of these chapters, tell us. We may follow up with researchers.

Sources:

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0

Comments (0)

User