52 Haredi Girls in Beit Shemesh Left Without School Mid-Year After the Education Ministry Refuses to Approve Their Classes

Israel’s Education Ministry did not approve grades 4–6 at Beit Yaakov Gur in Ramat Beit Shemesh Dalet, leaving 52 girls at home; the mayor is seeking a fix and the ministry cites the school’s license.

Nov 12, 2026 - 07:33
Updated: 10 days ago
0 8
52 Haredi Girls in Beit Shemesh Left Without School Mid-Year After the Education Ministry Refuses to Approve Their Classes
AI-generated editorial illustration.

Source: Instagram, @kikarhashabat. This report is an English translation of a Hebrew-language post.

View the original post on Instagram

BEIT SHEMESH, Israel — Fifty-two Haredi girls in the Ramat Beit Shemesh Dalet neighborhood have been left without a place in school in the middle of the school year. Israel's Education Ministry has refused to approve the fourth- through sixth-grade classes at the Beit Yaakov Gur girls' school, the Haredi news outlet Kikar HaShabbat reported on Wednesday, Nov. 11, 2026.

The story was posted in Hebrew on Kikar HaShabbat's Instagram account, @kikarhashabat, under the headline "52 Haredi students stayed home: the Education Ministry refused to approve the classes in Beit Shemesh." The full report, by Kikar HaShabbat reporter Kobi Israel, appeared on the outlet's website the same day. Quotations below are our translations from the Hebrew.

What happened

According to the Instagram post, the ministry refused to approve grades four through six at the school "due to non-compliance with the standard conditions." The full report explains that the problem is an issue known as "non-continuous standard": the number of pupils required to open a class that meets the ministry's standard.

Kikar HaShabbat reported that the school's first through third grades meet the standard and were formally approved. Those are four classes: two first-grade classes, one second-grade class and one third-grade class. The outlet said the sixth grade has 22 girls, while the fourth grade (16 girls) and fifth grade (15 girls) fell short of the required minimum. As a result, the higher grades were not approved and their pupils were left outside the school system. (The class-by-class figures published by the outlet add up to 53; its headline and Instagram post give the total as 52.)

The report said the school administration informed parents of the decision last week. As of Wednesday, the girls in the upper grades of the school, located at 4 Rav Mari Street, were staying home.

Parents: "Thrown into the street"

Parents reacted with anger. "We received the notice in complete shock," Ze'ev Weinreich, a Ramat Beit Shemesh Dalet resident who represents the school's parents' committee, told Kikar HaShabbat. "It is inconceivable that because of dry calculations of standards, 52 girls will be thrown into the street in the middle of the year. The girls are sitting at home crying, and the parents are helpless in the face of the Education Ministry's harsh bureaucracy."

According to the report, parents are demanding immediate emergency intervention to end what they called bureaucratic indifference.

City hall and the ministry respond

Beit Shemesh Mayor Shmuel Greenberg and his deputy, Hanoch Drenger, are working with the Education Ministry to find a solution, the Instagram post said. The full report described their effort as a search for an exceptional arrangement.

The Education Ministry gave Kikar HaShabbat a different account of where responsibility lies. "This is a privately owned school, and the responsibility for arranging the students' studies in accordance with the terms of the license rests with it," the ministry said. "The classes in question are not included in the license granted to the institution. Nevertheless, the Education Ministry is working together with the municipality and the owners to find a legal and optimal solution that will allow the students to continue their studies within a regulated framework as soon as possible."

The Instagram post summarized the ministry's position the same way. It said the ministry describes the institution as a private school whose license does not cover the classes in question, and that contacts with the municipality and the school's management are underway to find a legal solution so the girls can return to class quickly.

The wider picture

Ramat Beit Shemesh Dalet is a relatively new and fast-growing Haredi neighborhood in Beit Shemesh, west of Jerusalem. Local Haredi outlets, including Kikar HaShabbat and JDN, have previously reported classroom shortages at another girls' school in the neighborhood, Beit Yaakov Rama Dalet, linked to rapid enrollment growth. Kikar HaShabbat noted that the Beit Shemesh case comes alongside other education disputes that have surfaced recently, as Haredi religious school networks seek full autonomy and additional funding.

The ministry's response, as published by Kikar HaShabbat, did not give a timetable for the girls' return to class.

Sources:

  • @kikarhashabat on Instagram (Hebrew), post of Nov. 11, 2026: https://www.instagram.com/p/DfnfJD8x33p/
  • Kikar HaShabbat (Hebrew), Kobi Israel, "52 Haredi girls at home: the Education Ministry refused to approve the classes," Nov. 11, 2026 (1 Kislev 5787): https://www.kikar.co.il/haredim-news/beit-shemesh-girls-school-classes-rejected
  • JDN (Hebrew), earlier report on classroom shortages at Beit Yaakov Rama Dalet: https://www.jdn.co.il/municipal/2266049/
  • Beit Shemesh Municipality, list of Haredi elementary schools (Hebrew): https://www.betshemesh.muni.il/100950/

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0

Comments (0)

User